Home › Work, Careers & Leadership

Difficulty obtaining actionable professional feedback from managers

🧭 worksocial problem2 reports ●●●●● severity 3/5

An employee reports difficulty obtaining constructive criticism from their manager, who provides minimal feedback in formal reviews and is perceived to withhold negative feedback until termination, leaving the employee unsure how to improve their performance.

Who's affected: An employee working under a manager who provides sparse or non-existent performance feedback.

What people do today

🔧 Fix this

Ideas a builder, maker or community group could start on:

  1. A structured feedback template app that prompts managers to provide specific, categorized performance data on a monthly basis.
  2. A peer-to-peer feedback platform that allows employees to gather anonymous, constructive insights from colleagues to supplement manager reviews.
  3. A professional coaching service or workshop series that teaches employees how to facilitate 'radical candor' conversations with avoidant managers.
  4. An anonymous, structured feedback platform for employees to submit constructive, moderated performance insights to managers.
  5. A coaching service or template library specifically for subordinates on how to conduct 'upward feedback' conversations safely.
I want to build this

Real voices

“they are known to skimp on criticism until you find yourself fired from them”

Source: Stack Exchange (workplace) · CC BY-SA 4.0, user-contributed content from Stack Exchange; summarized and modified

“I would like to give feedback, but: I am not sure it is appropriate since I was not asked for it I do not know if I should address my teamleader directly or our common boss I checked how to give constructive feedback but still I fear retaliation”

Source: Stack Exchange (workplace) · CC BY-SA 4.0, user-contributed content from Stack Exchange; summarized and modified

Related problems

🧭 workproduct6 reports

Inability to filter AI-generated content on LinkedIn

●●●●● · A LinkedIn user and possibly others who find their professional feed cluttered with AI-generated content.
🧭 workproduct6 reports

Indeed job feed ignores user preferences

●●●●● · An Indeed job seeker and possibly others experiencing irrelevant job recommendations
🧭 worksocial6 reports

Difficulty setting boundaries with talkative senior colleague

●●●●● · An employee with a close, long-term relationship with a senior colleague.

FixHumanityDaily

The most important new problems, and ideas to fix them, in your inbox.

Placeholder: no data is collected yet.